A federal judge has issued a significant ruling in the ongoing legal battle regarding the NFL’s “Sunday Ticket” broadcast package. U.S. District Judge Philip Gutierrez granted a motion to overturn a massive jury verdict that previously ordered the league to pay $4.7 billion in damages.
The original jury decision, delivered earlier this year, found that the NFL violated antitrust laws by artificially inflating the price of the subscription service to protect its broadcast partnerships. However, the court has now determined that the plaintiffs failed to provide sufficient evidence to support the damages awarded by the jury.
In a formal order, Judge Gutierrez concluded that the evidence presented during the trial was legally insufficient, prompting him to vacate the judgment. The court noted that the expert testimony utilized by the plaintiffs to calculate consumer harm did not align with the requirements of antitrust law.
The league has maintained its position throughout the litigation that its distribution model is lawful and provides fans with multiple viewing options. Following the ruling, the NFL stated that it was “pleased with the court’s decision” to set aside the previous verdict.
This development marks a major reversal for the class-action plaintiffs, which included both residential subscribers and commercial establishments like bars and restaurants. The lawsuit had alleged that the league conspired with networks to restrict the availability of out-of-market games to maintain high pricing tiers.
Legal experts suggest that this ruling effectively resets a significant portion of the litigation. While the judge has vacated the award, the plaintiffs may choose to appeal the decision to a higher court, potentially prolonging the legal conflict for several more years.
The NFL continues to operate the Sunday Ticket service under its current agreement with Google’s YouTube, which began following the expiration of the previous contract with DirecTV. As the industry monitors the situation, the league remains focused on its broadcast strategy while preparing for potential future proceedings resulting from this judicial intervention.
