The Chino Valley Unified School District Board of Education voted 4-1 on Thursday to adopt a policy that prohibits biological males from participating in girls sports, locker rooms and showers.
The measure, titled Fairness in Girls’ Athletics and Privacy in Sex-Based Facilities, marks a shift for the district by establishing athletic eligibility based on biological sex at birth rather than gender identity.
Outgoing board President Sonja Shaw, who authored the policy, described the move as a necessary step to ensure student privacy and safety.
“These are common-sense measures: no boys competing in girls’ sports, no boys sharing girls’ locker rooms or showers, and no boys and girls sharing hotel rooms on school trips,” Shaw said according to Fox News.
The decision occurred despite a formal warning from the office of California Attorney General Rob Bonta.
In a letter sent Wednesday, Deputy Attorney General Edward Nugent urged the board to reject or delay the vote, citing potential conflicts with state law and Assembly Bill 1266.
Shaw rejected the state’s warning and argued that the district’s actions align with federal precedents.
The policy outlines that eligibility will generally be determined by enrollment records reflecting sex at or near birth.
If those records are unavailable or amended, the district may require a birth certificate or a statement from a licensed healthcare provider.
The regulations explicitly prohibit requiring students to undergo additional physical examinations or inspections beyond standard athletic protocols.
The vote followed a recent federal district court ruling that dismissed a lawsuit challenging state transgender athlete policies, though the court did not resolve the broader question of Title IX compliance.
The Chino Valley policy directs the superintendent to consult with legal counsel to protect the district’s interests and federal funding.
Shaw, who previously campaigned for state superintendent of public instruction, said she plans to continue advocating for similar requirements across other school districts.
“We are the first district in California to put these protections into formal board policy,” Shaw stated according to Fox News.
The board’s action sets the stage for a potential legal conflict between the district and state officials over the interpretation of educational codes and parental rights.
